The Child Maintenance System Is Under Fire: “Parents Are Breaking", And "Children Are Paying The Price”

---

The Child Maintenance Service (CMS) is facing growing criticism as new evidence and lived experiences reveal a system struggling to balance fairness, accountability, and the wellbeing of families.

Originally designed to ensure children are financially supported after separation, the system is now being described by many parents as financially and emotionally unsustainable.

A System Affecting Over One Million Children

Over 1 million children in the UK are supported through CMS arrangements

Around 710,000 paying parents, the majority fathers, are within the system

In Collect & Pay cases:-

• Up to 28% of parents pay nothing at all

• Only around 47% pay close to what they owe

At the same time:-

• Over 50% of receiving parents do not receive full payments

• Significant arrears remain across the system

These figures highlight a system that is failing to deliver consistency or fairness on either side.

Legal Framework, And Its Limitations

Child maintenance is governed by:-

• Child Support Maintenance Calculation Regulations 2012

• Administered by the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP)

Under current law:-

• Payments are calculated primarily on gross income

• There is no requirement to consider:-

  
  

  • Housing costs

  • Debt

  • Divorce settlements

  • Cost of living realities

  
  

This creates a rigid formula that many argue does not reflect real-life financial circumstances.

The Overlooked Reality for Paying Parents

A growing number of parents, many of them fathers,  are not refusing to pay.

They are struggling to survive after doing so.

Following separation, some have:-

• Given up the family home

• Paid significant financial settlements

• Divided pensions and savings

• Continued contributing to housing for their children

They then face;

A new CMS liability

With no recognition of what has already been provided

Many report being left:-

• Living in smaller or rented accommodation

• Managing debt from starting over

• Struggling to afford meaningful time with their children

Inequality and Loopholes

At the same time, concerns persist around fairness:

Some parents:-

• Fully declare income

• Pay on time

• Comply with the system

Others:-

• Under-declare earnings

• Manipulate business income

• Pay significantly reduced amounts

Cases of payments as low as £83 per month per child have been widely reported.

While legal in some circumstances, this disparity has raised serious concerns about equity and accountability.

The Mental Health Crisis Emerging Behind the System

Beyond finances, there is growing concern about mental health:-

• Men in the UK are three times more likely to die by suicide than women

• Research indicates separated fathers may face significantly higher mental health risks

Surveys suggest that a substantial proportion of paying parents experience:-

• Severe stress

• Depression

• Suicidal thoughts

Many report that financial pressure, combined with limited contact and ongoing conflict, is contributing to a sense of crisis.

This raises serious questions about whether the system is unintentionally contributing to a wider public health issue.

But Another Reality Must Be Acknowledged

For receiving parents, child maintenance is often not additional income.

It is essential.

Many single-parent households rely on one income

Childcare limits working capacity

Living costs continue to rise

When maintenance is not paid:-

• Children may go without basic essentials

• Financial hardship increases

• Inequality deepens

Financial and Economic Abuse, A Missing Consideration

Under the Domestic Abuse Act 2021, financial and economic abuse is legally recognised.

This includes:-

• Controlling access to money

• Restricting employment

• Creating financial dependency

• Hiding or manipulating assets

However, many argue this is not adequately reflected in CMS calculations, leaving some parents,  particularly survivors  at a continued disadvantage.

A System Criticised at the Highest Level

The National Audit Office has raised concerns about:-

• Accuracy of assessments

• Arrears and enforcement challenges

• Overall effectiveness of the system

These findings reinforce concerns that the current model is not working as intended.

The Core Issue: A System Not Built for Real Life

Currently, key systems operate in isolation:-

• Divorce settlements handled by courts

• Child maintenance handled by CMS

• Income verification through HMRC

Families, however, live within one financial reality;

The lack of coordination creates gaps that many parents fall into.

The Truth That Must Be Faced

Both of the following are true:-

• Some parents are being pushed into financial hardship trying to pay

• Some parents cannot meet their children’s needs without maintenance

• Some have already contributed significantly

• Some have been left with nothing

• Some exploit the system

• Some are trapped within it

Call for Reform

Campaigners and parents are calling for urgent reform, including:-

• Greater financial transparency, particularly for self-employed income

• Recognition of prior financial settlements where appropriate

• Consideration of real living costs

• Stronger enforcement for non-payment

• Integration between CMS, courts, and HMRC

• Proper recognition of financial and economic abuse

The Hard Truth 

This is not about mothers versus fathers.

It is about children.

Children deserve stability in both homes

No parent should be pushed into poverty to prove they care

Financial systems should not contribute to mental health crises

Final Statement

Children do not understand legal formulas or financial loopholes.

They understand:-

• Stability

• Presence

• Support

If the system fails to deliver those things, then reform is not optional.

It is overdue.

---

Deanna Newell Family Law

Advocacy for truth-tellers, survivors, and the children who deserve better