Legal Systems Overwhelmed by Misuse of Parental Alienation Allegations in Domestic Abuse and Coercive Control Cases

---

False allegations of parental alienation—increasingly used to deflect from genuine concerns about domestic abuse, coercive control, and financial or economic abuse—are placing an unsustainable burden on the family court system.

A particularly concerning trend is the rise of “financial alienation,” where one parent manipulates legal processes not to protect a child’s welfare, but to secure financial advantage. This often coincides with attempts to avoid child maintenance or shift the economic balance of power during separation.

Against the backdrop of a post-pandemic economy, rising living costs, and widespread financial instability, these tactics are more prevalent—and more damaging—than ever.

The Hidden Cost to Families and the Justice System

When false alienation claims are weaponised:

• Genuine safeguarding concerns may be dismissed.

• Vulnerable children can be left in unsafe environments.

• Police and social services are pulled into unnecessary interventions.

• Court resources are stretched, delaying justice for families in crisis.

At its worst, this misuse traumatises victims, erodes public trust, and undermines the integrity of the entire family justice system.

Promoting Healthy Co-Parenting Over Legal Combat

A healthier first step is to promote child-focused, cooperative parenting. Not all post-separation conflict requires courtroom intervention.

We need to prioritise:

• Evidence-based parenting programmes

• Early intervention and mediation

• Services that equip parents to resolve disputes without escalating conflict

These tools help reframe separation around children’s emotional wellbeing, not adult grievances or financial scorekeeping.

Reforming the Legal Framework

To meet this growing crisis, the family court system must be equipped to accurately distinguish genuine abuse from manipulative legal tactics. Key reforms should include:

• Mandatory training for judges, magistrates, CAFCASS officers, and legal professionals in coercive control, post-separation abuse, and the misuse of alienation claims

• A move from the subjective “balance of probabilities” to a more forensic, evidence-based model—especially in cases with serious safeguarding concerns

• Independent psychological assessments and holistic family welfare evaluations

• Accountability measures for parties who deliberately mislead the court, including cost orders, sanctions, or changes to contact and financial arrangements

Addressing Financial Motives and Economic Abuse

When courts find that false allegations have been made to gain financial advantage, this behaviour should be formally recognised as economic abuse under the umbrella of coercive control.

Courts should have powers to:

• Reassess child maintenance, ensuring fair and equitable support for children

• Impose financial consequences if litigation was prolonged unnecessarily or the other party incurred substantial legal costs defending false claims

Such consequences would act as a deterrent and help preserve court time and resources for families genuinely in need.

The Wider Impact on Society

The weaponisation of parental alienation is not just a private issue. It’s a systemic crisis with far-reaching consequences:

• It diverts police and social services from real safeguarding threats

• It burdens mental health teams dealing with traumatised children and parents

• It risks failing the very children it claims to protect

The Call to Action

To restore trust in the family justice system and safeguard vulnerable children, we must:

• Demand truth and transparency in legal proceedings

• Recognise the misuse of parental alienation as a systemic issue

• Support reforms that protect both justice and the best interests of children

Only through evidence-based practice, legal accountability, and trauma-informed compassion can we begin to rebuild a family court system that truly protects the vulnerable.

Family Courts in Crisis

False parental alienation claims are flooding the system—often used to deflect from abuse or manipulate child maintenance. This misuse delays justice, harms children, and wastes vital resources.

We need:

• Mandatory training on coercive control

• Independent psychological assessments

• Accountability for false allegations

• Recognition of financial alienation as economic abuse

Let’s reform the system to protect the children — and families — who need it most.

---

Deanna Newell Family Law

Advocacy for truth-tellers, survivors, and the children who deserve better